!Under Construction!
Some Abstracts from 1999 - 2008
CECÍLIA GALVÃO, PEDRO REIS, SOFIA FREIRE
A Big Problem for Magellan: Food Preservation.
ABSTRACT: In this paper, we present data related to how a
Portuguese teacher developed the module A big problem for
Magellan: Food preservation. Students were asked to plan an
investigation in order to identify which were the best food
preservation methods in the XV and XVI centuries of Portuguese
overseas navigation, and then establish a parallel between those
methods and current ones. Students were involved in discussing
the relationship between science and social issues, and about
the impact that science evolution has on daily life practices.
The teacher had professional experience and a Masters degree in
science
education and considered that PARSEL and the specific module
constituted a good approach to achieve his goals concerning
science education. Students were attending a twelfth-grade
biology class and wished to pursue university studies in science.
We carried outparticipant observations, interviews with the
teacher and four of his students, and we also administered a
questionnaire to the students. Both teacher and students found
the module popular and relevant for their lives. Despite
positive assessment, some less positive issues, such as, time
management and module extension, and the difficulty of making a
connection
between science and social issues were also identified.
KEYWORDS: Popularity, relevance, science education
CLAUS BOLTE
A Conceptual Framework for the Enhancement of Popularity and
Relevance of Science Education for Scientific Literacy
ABSTRACT: Science educators express wide consensus about the
importance of a modern scientific literate society. But
focussing on the public understanding of science in Germany,
there seems to be no general consensus, neither about how to
enhance scientific literacy in the educational practice nor
about what the major topics and dimensions of a modern science
education are. With the help of the Curricular Delphi-Study in
Chemistry (CDSC) a working group, this study analyzed topics and
dimensions as well'as fields of dissent and consensus in the
opinions of 114 experts from different stakeholder groups (students,
teachers, educators, and scientists). Knowledge about this helps
to improve science lessons and makes clear that projects, like
PARSEL, are urgently need to enhance the popularity and
relevance of science'education for scientific literacy.
KEYWORDS: Delphi study, stakeholder views, popularization,
relevance, scientific literacy.
Mercè Izquierdo, Conxita Márquez, and Guaracira Gouvea
A Proposal for Textbooks Analysis: Rhetorical Structures
ABSTRACT: The present study relates to a research line in
didactics of science that focuses on the function that sign
systems or semiotic modes have in communicative interactions in
science classrooms. The study was conducted by 20 secondary and
university science teachers who belong to the same research
group LIEC (Language and Science Teaching) at the Universitat
Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB). This group is devoted to the study
of the relations between language and science teaching, and is
centred on the analysis of textbooks, because these are still
the most used didactical mediators in science teaching. The
study
attempted to construct indicators in order to investigate
whether textbooks are adequate fordidactical intervention. Such
an investigation would provide useful information for better
strategies both to read in class and to write more innovative
textbooks from a didactical point of view, i.e., textbooks that
are more appropriate to support students autonomous work in
science classrooms.
Keywords: Chemistry, rethorics, textbooks
HÜLYA YILMAZ ,HAKAN TÜRKMEN
An Accurate Picture of What is Currently Happening in Turkish
Science Classrooms
ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to investigate the extent
to which primary science teachers understand the new reform
implemented in Turkey and to examine their perceptions regarding
science instruction. Thus, it could be possible to show an
accurate picture of what is currently happening in
primary'science classrooms and identify the kind of support
primary science teachers may need. In this study, a survey was
distributed to all in-service primary school science teachers in
the area of Izmir,Turkey. The sample consisted of 389 primary
science teachers from 72 primary schools. This study was carried
out using quantitative and qualitative methodologies. The Survey
on K-12 Science Education was used for collecting quantitative
data. For collecting the qualitative data, primary science
teachers were asked to specify the main goals in their teaching
science and what would help them in achieving these goals. The
results showed that they were not enough actively engaged in
classroom science activities, and that they should be trained to
apply more effective teaching approaches, and how to integrate
science with other subject areas and real life.
KEY WORDS: Science education, science teaching, Turkish
education.
CLAUS MICHELSEN
Between Teaching and Researching: Envisaging Ownership Benefits
of Involving Teachers from an In-service Teacher Training
Program in the PARSEL Project
ABSTRACT: The Danish PARSEL team included 5 teachers from the
region of Southern Denmark, of whom two enjoyed special status.
These two teachers have been trained to develop, implement, and
evaluate interventional modules similar to those of PARSEL,
through a one year full-time equivalent masters degree program
in science and mathematics education. This program took its lead
from the model of educational reconstruction, and this engaged
the participating teachers in having an intimate contact with
researchers in implementation and evaluation processes very
similar to the trying out phase of the PARSEL project. This
paper presents the teachers background in the form of the
masters degree program; it presents the teachers comments on the
PARSEL project and the individual modules; and it moves to
discuss and envisage special outcomes regarding ownership of
PARSEL modules for intimate partnerships between teachers and
researchers.
KEYWORDS: Educational reconstruction, professional development,
teacher-researcher collaboration
KAI PATA, ENEKEN METSALU
Conceptualizing Awareness in Environmental Education: An Example
of Knowing about Air-related Problems
ABSTRACT The notion of environmental awareness has been
controversial in environmental literacy. Environmental awareness
has been traditionally understood as conceptual awareness, but
this study takes into consideration activity-related aspects of
awareness, which should be integrated into an ontological model
of developing environmental literacy. The empirical part of the
study investigated the components of conceptual awareness using
the model of air-related environmental issues. Eight classes of
students (N=204) filled in an open-ended questionnaire one week
after teaching about environmental issues was completed. The
questionnaire investigated the extent of their awareness
regarding the greenhouse effect, the depletion of ozone layer,
acid rain and air pollution at general and local level. The
teachers of the eight classes answered a different questionnaire
relating to the teaching methods they used. The findings
indicated that the students exhibited in their answers both
conceptual and activity-related components of environmental
awareness, and they faced difficulties in combining global and
local aspects of environmental issues. Three types of students
were identified on the basis of their awareness about the
examined air-related issues: with mainly task- and process
related and contextual awareness, with mainly social and
contextual awareness, and with awareness where all aspects were
combined. The active stu-dent-centred teaching method was
related with the development of mainly the social and contextual
awareness. Some students who participated in student-centred
activities outdoors belonged to the awareness type in which
task- and process-related contextual awareness was prevalent.
The teacher-centred traditional methods developed both task-
and process- related, and social and contextual awareness
components.
KEYWORDS: Acid rain, air pollution, environmental awareness,
environmental literacy, greenhouse effect, ozone layer
depletion.
ANDREAS CHIRAS, NICOS VALANIDES
Day/night Cycle: Mental Models of Primary School Children
ABSTRACT The study investigated the mental models of primary
school children related to the day/night cycle. Semi-structure
interviews were conducted with 40 fourth-grade and 40 sixth-grade
children. Qualitative and quantitative analysis of the data
indicated that the majority of the children were classified as
having geocentric models. The results also indicated that a
large number of primary school children did not appropriately
conceptualize the essential prerequisites for understanding the
day/night cycle, and that their observational skills were
limited. It was also concluded that childrens age (class) and
their mathematical achievement were good predictors for the
quality of their mental models.
KEYWORDS: Alternative conceptions, day/night cycle, mental
models
Pierre Clement, Lassaad Mouelhi, Mohamed Kochkar, Nikos
Valanides, Olia Nisiforou,Seyni Mame Thiaw, Valdiodio Ndiaye,
Paula Jeanbart, Daniel Horvath,
Do the Images of Neuronal Pathways in the Human Central Nervous
System Show Feed-back ? A Comparative Study in Fifteen Countries
ABSTRACT: In the human brain, the neuronal pathways are networks
which support our learning, memory and thought, and which work
with permanent feedback. However, only 19% of illustrations of
these neuronal pathways, in the 55 analysed school textbooks
coming from 15 countries, were showing feedbacks. The neuronal
pathways related to movements were generally introduced by
linear spinal cord reflexes, and sometimes mostly reduced to
reflexes. In consequence, in most countries, the scientific
knowledge taught with these images of neuronal pathways was
linked with an implicit ideology: A clear behaviourism
associated with reductionism, and even sometimes with innatism
or spiritualism. Two thirds of the few images with feedback were
related to vegetative functions: the neuro-hormonal control of
female and male reproduction, and of heart and breathing rhythms.
Nevertheless, even for these vegetative controls, there was not
any feedback in several of the 55 analysed textbooks. Only in
three countries, the double innervation (gamma and alpha) of
striated muscles, with the regulatory function of the neuro-muscular
spindle, was illustrated with only one image in each of the
three corresponding textbooks. Few images illustrated neuronal
pathways in the brain, and only exceptionally as the neuronal
networks (with feedback)which are the supports of our memory and
of our thought. The persistence of the same kind of images in
school textbooks of these contrasted countries suggest that the
conceptionsof human brain are less linked to national socio-cultural
contexts rather than to international dominant ideologies.
KEYWORDS: Feedbacks, human brain, school textbooks.
CHRIS KING, PETER KENNETT, and ELIZABETH DEVON
Earthlearningidea Update
There have been many Earthlearningidea developments since our
update in August. By early November, we had over 8500 visits to
our site from 115 countries and we have decided to continue the
project into 2009. However, for next year, we are asking you to
contribute; details of what to do can be found on the home page
of our website www.earthlearningidea.com. Throughout next year,
we shall be publishing
one new activity per month. Also, on the home page, you will
find an invitation to evaluate the ideas; the results of these
evaluations should help future educators to use their time and
resources most effectively to support global learning.
HULYA YILMAZ , HAKAN TURKMEN
Evaluating Science Education Reform via Fourth-Grade Students
Image of Science Teaching
ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to investigate fourth-grade
students image of current science teaching by using a Draw-A-Science-Teacher-Test
Checklist (DASTT-C), and give a glance whether the new
restructured science education reform in Turkey is implemented
successfully or not. Fifty-five (34 girls and 21 boys) fourth-grade
students from three different primary schools participated in
this study. The results of study showed that 18.2% of Turkish
fourth-grade students view their science classrooms as student-centered,
56.4% as neither student-centered nor teacher-centered, and
25.4% as teacher-centered. These results indicate that Turkey is
in the process of a big positive change, and that traditional
education perspective started switching over to constructivist
perspective, while attempts for implementing the reform put
emphasis on elementary teachers and their professional
development.
KEYWORDS: Curriculum development, DASTT-C, science education
reform
MEHMET ERDOGAN, MUHAMMET USAK
Examining Prospective Science Teachers Satisfaction with Their
Department
ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to explore how satisfied
prospective science teachers are with their department (academic
staff and administration) at different Faculties of Education in
Turkey. For'this purpose, Prospective Science Teachers
Satisfaction Questionnaire (PSTSQ) was developed by considering
related literature. PSTSQ consists of two parts and seven
dimensions, namely, General Satisfaction, Administration,
Curriculum, Academic Staff, Facilities, Skills Promoted by
Courses and Laboratory and its Facilities, respectively. In
order to explore prospective teachers satisfaction level, PSTSQ
was administered to 410 fourth-year students who enrolled in
science education programs at six different Faculties of
Education. The participants of the study were asked to respond
to the 82 items on'a 5 point Likert-scale (1=strongly disagree
and 5=strongly agree). The reliability analysis indicated
that'the Cronbachs alpha reliability coefficient ( ·) of the
instrument was 0.89. For the purpose of the present'study, only
the administration and academic staff dimensions of the
questionnaire were used. The participants reported that they
were dissatisfied with some aspects of their department, but
there was no'significant mean difference between male and female
students. On the contrary, significant mean differences among
students from different universities in terms of their
satisfaction with their departments were found.
KEY WORDS: Academic department, prospective science teacher,
satisfaction.
JACK HOLBROOK
Foreword- Introduction to the Special Issue of Science Education
International Devoted to PARSEL
This special issue of the ICASE journal is devoted to the PARSEL
project. This project is supported by a European Commission
grant SAS6-CT-2006-042922- PARSEL. Why is PARSEL considered
important for readers ? This is answered from three perspectives.
1. This project is geared to identifying and structuring
teaching materials for enhancing scientific literacy among
secondary school students. ICASE has been involved in the need
to recognize the attributes of scientific and technological
literacy for many years and, together with UNESCO, co-chaired an
international conference in this area is 1993. ICASE feels it
has a mandate from its member organizations to consider this an
area of importance for further promotion. 2. ICASE is a partner
in this project and has played a strong role in guiding the type
of teaching materials to be developed. ICASE feels these
teaching materials will be of interest to its member
organizations, either in totality, or by adopting the PARSEL 3-stage
model through modifications that better suit the local situation.
3. These materials go further that simply providing science
teaching material that relate to the subject content of the
curriculum. The materials promote a wider view of science
education and guide teachers to consider student involvement in
inquiry based investigations, the development of communication
skills above and beyond written records and also the need to
include socio-scientific decision making in science teaching.
PARSEL teaching modules are to be found on the following website
www.parsel.eu. All modules are in English, but selected modules
also appear on national websites in German, Portuguese, Hebrew,
Swedish, Danish, Estonian and Greek. The modules indicate the
grade level for which they are written and are ready for teacher
use in total or in part.
Pitombo, Maiana Albuquerque, Ana Maria Rocha de Almeida and
Charbel Niño El-Hani
Gene Concepts in Higher Education Cell and Molecular Biology
Textbooks
ABSTRACT: Despite being a landmark of 20th century biology, the
classical molecular gene concept, according to which a gene is a
stretch of DNA encoding a functional product, which may be a
single
polypeptide or RNA molecule, has been recently challenged by a
series of findings (e.g., split genes, alternative splicing,
overlapping and nested genes, mRNA edition, etc). The debates
about the gene concept have important implications on biology
teaching, and, thus, it is important to investigate whether and
how these are addressed in this context. In this paper, we
report results of an investigation relating to the treatment of
genes in higher education cell and molecular biology textbooks.
These results indicate that, despite several findings
challenging time-honored ideas about genes, these ideas continue
to be widely used in textbooks, even though the textbooks
themselves discuss part of those findings. Textbooks also harbor
a proliferation of meanings about genes that may make the
concept look vague and confused, and even lead to ideas that are
at odds with our current knowledge about genomes.
KEYWORDS: Biology teaching, gene, higher education, textbooks.
Jérémy Castéra, Pierre Clément, Mondher Abrougui, Olympia
Nisiforou, Nicos Valanides,Tago Sarapuu, Jurga Turcinaviciene,
Boujemaa Agorram, Florbela Ca
Genetic Determinism in School Textbooks:A Comparative Study
Conducted Among Sixteen Countries
ABSTRACT: Genetic concepts have significantly evolved over the
last ten years, and are now less connected to innate ideas and
reductionism. Unique reference to genetic determinism has been
replaced by the interaction between the genes and their
environment (epigenetics). Our analyses relate to how current
school biology textbooks present this new paradigm in 16
different countries (12 from Europe, and Tunisia, Morocco,
Senegal, and Lebanon). Two precise criteria were used to analyse
and compare the chapters dealing with the topic Human Genetics.
The first criterion was the occurrence of the expression genetic
program (which is typical of innate values). This was present in
the textbooks of some countries, but were totally missing in
some others. The existing differences seem to support the
following: (i) in Eastern European countries, the absence is
long-standing, and it is possibly linked to a previous influence
of Lyssenko, (ii) in some other countries, the absence could be
linked to various reactions during the Nazi period, (iii) in
other cases, the observed diminution might be due to a
modernisation of the scientific content, and, finally, (iv) in
several countries, the notion of genetic program is still
present, without any attempt for
change. In contrast, there were no differences between countries
with relation to the second criterion, that is, the twins
pictures present in the textbooks. The monozygotic twins were
always dressed identically, and had the same hairstyle and body
posture, as if these features could be genetically determined,
providing thus evidence of a persistent implicit deterministic
ideology. These results are discussed as interactions between
implicit values and taughtscientific knowledge.
KEY WORDS: Human genetics, school textbooks, twins.
CHOKCHAI YUENYONG, JIRAKARN YUENYONG
Grade 1 to 6 Thai Students Existing Ideas about Energy
ABSTRACT This study explored 30 Grade 1 to 6 (6 12 years old)
Thai students existing ideas about energy. The study employed
the Interview about Event (IAE) approach. During IAE, the cards
of an
event or things were showed to students in order to probe their
views of energy concepts. Findings indicated that young students
held various alternative conceptions about energy that could be
categorized into five different groups relating to electric
energy, potential energy, mechanical energy and forces, heat
energy, and fuel. Most of Grade 1 to 3 students considered
energy as mainly mechanical energy and forces, or electric
energy, while the majority of Grade 4 to 6 students clarified
their ideas about energy by referring to potential and electric
energy. The paper discusses the findings and their implications
for teaching and learning with reference to a teaching unit that
was developed and evaluated using Thai primary school students.
KEY WORDS: Energy, transformations of energy, teaching and
learning.
KATERINA MALAMITSA , PANAGIOTIS KOKKOTAS
Graph/Chart Interpretation and Reading Comprehension as Critical
Thinking Skills
ABSTRACT: In contemporary academic literature and in many
national curricula, there is a widespread acceptance that
critical thinking should be an important dimension of Education.
Teachers and researchers recognize the importance of developing
students critical thinking, but there are still great
difficulties in defining and assessing critical-thinking skills.
The multiple definitions of critical thinking indicate the need
for further clarification of the concept. An important attempt
for clarifying the concept was the Delphi Report (Facione,
1990a), where a qualitative research methodology, known as the
Delphi Method, was used
to develop a unified theoretical framework. The core critical-thinking
skills identified in the Delphi Report as essential elements for
workplace and educational success are targeted in the assessment
tool entitled The Test of Everyday Reasoning (TER) (Facione,
2001). TERwas translated from English into Greek and
standardized for Greek population. TER has a series of questions
engaging the participant in the interpretation and reasoning
relating to the information provided in charts and graphs as
well as to the accompanying them textual description. This paper
presents the results from the standardization of TER in terms of
graph/chart interpretation and reading comprehension skills.
Implications for science education in Greece are also discussed.
KEYWORDS: Science education, Test of Everyday Reasoning (TER),
visual literacy
Peter Borrows
Health and Safety in Practical Science in Schools : A UK
Perspective
ABSTRACT The tendency for the press and public to over-react on
safety. The need to balance risk against benefit. The difference
between hazard and risk. Preventative or protective steps (control
measures) to reduce the risk from particular hazards. Examples
in school science, including the use of eye protection and
alternative strategies, if eye protection is not available. The
ability of teachers to supervise a class dependent on the size
of the class. The need for supervision dependent on the nature
of the practical activity and the risk involved in it, as well
as the nature of the class, and the skills and behaviour of the
students.
KEYWORDS: Class size, health and safety, risk assessment
PETER BORROWS
Health and Safety in Practical Science in Schools:A UK
Perspective 2, Using Model Risk Assessments
The previous article in this series explained the difference
between hazard (something which could cause harm) and risk (a
combination of the likelihood and magnitude of harm actually
being caused by the hazard). If the risk is too high,steps must
be taken to reduce it to a sufficiently low level by adopting
suitable protective (control) measures. If a practical activity
in a science lesson has some risk associated with it then one
way of reducing the risk might be to avoid the activity
altogether. In that case, very little practical work would ever
take place. If you are using glass apparatus, there is always a
possibility of breakage and hence cuts. If you are using hot
apparatus, there is always the possibility of burns. We accept a
low level of risk because the benefit of practical science
outweighs the risks. Teaching students how to handle safely
fragile or hot objects under the relatively organised conditions
of a science lesson may teach them something of value about risk
management for life outside the laboratory and when they have
left school.
Marie-Pierre Quessada, Pierre Clément, Britta Oerke, and
Adriana Valente
Human Evolution in Science Textbooks from Twelve Different
Countries
ABSTRACT: What kinds of images of human beings illustrate human
evolution in school textbooks? A comparison between the
textbooks of eighteen different countries (twelve European
countries and six non-European countries) was attempted. In six
countries (Algeria, Malta, Morocco, Mozambique, Portugal, and
Tunisia), we did not find any chapter on the topic of human
evolution in the textbooks consulted. When analysing all the
images in the human evolution chapters in the 30 textbooks from
the other twelve countries, we found that the great majority of
these images show adult males, few images show females
(one female for every four males), very few show children (one
child for every nine adults), few images show ethnic diversity (one
image with ethnic diversity for every eight images without
ethnic diversity). When analyzing the images of timelines or
trees depicting human evolution, we found in all the chapters on
biological evolution the representation of Homo sapiens, who was
found in 28 textbooks from twelve different countries. Homo
sapiens is nearly always an archetype of a male with white skin,
either naked or dressed in occidental clothing. Only in four
cases, there was also a woman (and never a woman alone), such as
in a
Lithuanian textbook as well as in a French one, an Italian one,
and a German one. This last German image is a unique one where
ethnic diversity was illustrated by three people. These results
show that scientific messages related to the origins of
humankind are generally mixed with implicit values. It is
important to identify these values, whilst teaching this topic,
in order to favour the ability of students to develop a critical
outlook for better citizenship.
KEYWORDS: Human evolution, images of humankind, science
textbooks
SHU-NU CHANG
Implementing Science across the World in a Resource-Based
Learning Activity regarding Sustainable Development Issues
ABSTRACT The rapid development of science and technology has
become a global issue in modern society, since it will not only
bring conveniences into peoples lives but it may also cause
extensive environmental damage to the planet earth. Therefore,
it is important to propagate the notion of Science Technology
and Society (STS) and the awareness of sustainable development.
The purpose of this study was to implement a Science across the
World (SAW) activity in a resource-based environment regarding
two sustainable issues, global warming and renewable energy, and
to investigate students responses to this SAW activity. Seventy-eight
non-science major freshmen participated in the study. The
results from participants questionnaires indicated that students
felt most interested in exploring ideas locally via Internet,
and exchanging information with students from other countries
globally. Through this activity, students also presented the
positive results of the acquisition of knowledge, and they felt
that their inquiry abilities got improved. Implication of STS
teaching on students learning and attitudes are discussed.
KEY WORDS: Resource-based learning, science across the world,
STS, sustainable development.
RON BLONDER, MIRA KIPNIS, RACHEL MAMLOK-NAAMAN, AVI HOFSTEIN
Increasing Science Teachers Ownership through the Adaptation of
the PARSEL Modules: A Bottom-up Approach
ABSTRACT: The study describes the process of adopting new
curriculum materials, which had been developed in the PARSEL
project in several European countries, into the local
educational science classroom of another country. The goal of
the PARSEL project was to raise the popularity and relevance of
science teaching by enhancing students scientific and
technological literacy and by identifying suitable teaching/learning
materials, based on relevant context-based educational
approaches. All PARSEL materials are organized in a website and
are freely accessible by science teachers around the world. In
order to increase the teachers ownership towards the new
materials, a bottom-up approach that included a teacher workshop
for modifying the PARSEL modules for the needs of teachers was
implemented.
The teachers used the modified modules in their classes and
reflect upon the whole process, after it was completed. Data
have been collected using various research tools, such as,
teachers questionnaires, teachers interviews and teachers focus
group interviews. The results indicate that the bottom-up
process increased teacher ownership towards the PARSEL modules
and helped the teachers to align their teaching with the
philosophy and the teaching style of the PARSEL project. It was
also indicated that the students found the modules to be popular
and interesting.
KEYWORDS: Adopting new curriculum, bottom-up strategies,
popularity, relevance,teachers ownership.
Pierre Clement
Introduction to the Special Issue of SEI Relating to Critical
Analysis of School Science Textbooks
The use of school textbooks strongly differs from one country to
another. In some cases, the textbook is used like the bible, and
students should prepare the lesson, for example, of biology by
reading one chapter, and the lesson is mainly an explanation of
the chapter paragraph by paragraph. Students try to understand,
summarize, and finally know the content by heart. In other
countries, the textbook is only a tool besides many other tools.Teachers
and learners can use the textbook depending on the lesson or the
context and, in some cases, the textbook is not used at all.
Nevertheless, in all cases, the school textbooks are aligned to
the syllabus and represent the way of teaching in the respective
country. Critical analysis of textbooks is thus interesting,
even without having any information of the way they are used,
and reflects, to a certain extent, aspects of the real classroom
situation in any country.
DECLAN KENNEDY
Linking Learning Outcomes and Assessment of Learning of Student
Science Teachers
ABSTRACT: The signing of the Bologna Agreement in 1999 has major
implications for all involved in third level education
throughout the world. By 2010 in the 45 countries that have
signed up to the Bologna process, all modules and programmes in
third level institutions will be written in terms of learning
outcomes. In addition, many countries outside the Bologna
process are aligning their third-level educational systems to be
compatible with the Bologna process in order to facilitate
description of qualifications, mutual recognition of degrees,
and mobility of students. This paper covers the background to
the concept of Learning Outcomes, the use of Blooms Taxonomy to
write learning outcomes, the relationship between learning
outcomes and competences, and the linking of learning outcomes
to both teaching and learning activities as well as to
assessment. In addition, the author discusses the effects of the
introduction of learning outcomes into the teacher-training
programme for science teachers in his own university with
particular reference to the assessment of student learning.
KEYWORDS: Aims, assessment, Bologna Agreement, learning outcomes,
objectives.
KENNETH RUSSELL ROY
Safety in the Hood!
On 15 June 2006, one of the United States California - adopted
safety regulations
titled Ventilation Requirements for Laboratory-type Hood
Operations. By definition, a Laboratory-Type Hood is a device
enclosed except for necessary exhaust purposes on three sides
and top and bottom,
designed to draw air inward by means of mechanical ventilation,
operated with insertion of only the hands and arms of the user,
and used to control exposure to hazardous substances.
Whitfield Green, and Devika Naidoo Science Textbooks in the
Context of Political Reform in South Africa:Whitfield Green, and
Devika Naidoo
ABSTRACT: The post-apartheid National Physical Science
Curriculum was implemented for the first time in South Africa in
grade 10 during 2006. A variety of new textbooks for grade 10
have been published. This study was a comparative analysis of
three popular textbooks, one prepared to support the previous
curriculum, and two prepared for the new curriculum. The study
employed an eclectic theoretical approach and a mixed mode (qualitative
and quantitative) methodology. The comparative analysis of the
three textbooks showed that the old textbook presented pure,
decontextualised physical science knowledge; presented
conventional academic hard science knowledge as strongly
separated from the real world; and assumed that English was the
first language of students. It emphasized factual and conceptual
knowledge that students must remember and understand. It was
underpinned by an objectivist epistemology and a rationalist
philosophy of knowledge. One of the new textbooks was similar to
the old. The other new textbook was inclusive, and presented
science knowledge using a popular format and an interactive
style. In addition to academic science knowledge, utilitarian
knowledge was also presented. There was also an emphasis on
factual and conceptual knowledge that students must remember and
understand. The boundaries between science and the real world
were weakened, and an obvious attempt to incorporate indigenous
knowledge in the textbook was made. The new textbook seemed to
be less mono-cultural, white, Eurocentric, and male-centered.
Various language tools mediated English for second-language
learners. In addition, it situated science knowledge in social,historical,
and cultural experiences that students could identify with.
Meta-cognitive reflection on the acquisition of academic and
social competencies was consistently expected and
there was also an expectation for higher cognitive processes,
such as, analysis and evaluation. The textbook was underpinned
by a social-constructivist epistemology and a humanistic
philosophy of knowledge. The findings of this study support the
conclusion that the new textbooks differ in terms of their
potential to improve access to science for groups which have
historically been marginalized.
Key words: Equity, knowledge representation, social
representation, textbook analysis.
THEMOS APOSTOLIDES, NIKOS VALANIDES
Secondary School StudentsConceptions Relating to Motion under
Gravity
ABSTRACT: The study investigated tenth-, eleventh-, and twelfth-grade
students alternative ideas relating to the motion of a body
travelling in the field of gravity with an initial horizontal
velocity. The sample of the study consisted of 40 tenth-grade
students, and 33 and 40 eleventh-grade students that attended
different sections of upper secondary school where the time
devoted to physics teaching is quite diverse. Open-ended
questions related to three different problems were used. The
first problem concerned the motion of a metallic ball after
reaching the edge of a horizontal surface on which it was moving
with constant velocity.
The second problem concerned the motion of a ball, which was
held in the hands of a runner who was moving on a horizontal
surface with constant velocity, after the ball was released by
the runner. The third problem concerned the motion of a body
that was thrown upwards from a vehicle that was moving
horizontally with constant velocity. Students answers were
analyzed qualitatively and were grouped into different
categories based on their main conceptual characteristics.
Students conceptions were similar to the pre-Newtonian theories
of motion, resembling to Aristotles ideas about motion and
aspects of the theory of impetus, developed by Buridan during
Middle Ages. Comparison of students answers to the three similar
problems indicated students difficulties to transfer the same
conceptual framework from one problem to the other. Differences
also existed among the three Groups of students that differed in
terms of their educational experiences. Based on the results,
suggestions related to curriculum revisions and constructivistic
teaching interventions are put forward.
KEYWORDS: Alternative perceptions, constructivism, inertia,
independence of motions.
Sandie Bernard, Pierre Clément, Graça Carvalho, Alves Gilda,
Dominique Berger,Seyni Mame Thiaw, Selmaoui Sabah, Khzami
Salaheddine, Grita Skujiene, Sa
Sexually Transmitted Infections and the Use of Condoms in
Biology Textbooks.A Comparative Analysis Across Sixteen
Countries
ABSTRACT: Our study focused on two topics, Sexually Transmitted
Infections (STIs) and their control using condoms. For this, we
analysed and compared 42 school textbooks from 16 countries on
the general topic Human Reproduction and Sex Education using a
specific grid designed by the BIOHEAD-Citizen project. Acquired
Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) was a common topic in all the
textbooks that were analyzed, although it appeared in quite
different chapters, such as, Human Procreation (the control of
reproduction, the hygiene of reproduction, or in chapters
devoted to STIs and AIDS), Immunology (with AIDS as an example
of immune deficiency), and Personal Protection.Some textbooks
provided information about other STIs in addition to AIDS. There
appeared important differences among countries concerning both
the number of images in the textbooks and the number of STIs
that were discussed in the textbooks. There were also
differences among various textbooks addressing the same
educational level that came from
different publishers in terms of the way that STIs were
presented. More than half of the analyzed textbooks did not link
the presentation of STIs with their prevention via the use of
condoms, and only a few textbooks illustrated an unrolled male
condom on the penis. Our results also indicated that (i) for
most of the analyzed biology textbooks there was a preference
for the biomedical model of health education that provided
sufficient scientific knowledge, (ii) only in Finland, there was
an attempt for promoting competencies relating to a healthy
sexual behaviour, and (iii) the textbooks from Morocco and
Tunisia illustrated how traditional values could be promoted in
parallel with biomedical knowledge by using injunctive moral
content. Interactions between scientific knowledge (K), values
(V), and social practices (P) had been found and seemed to
determine what was present (and how)in school textbooks.
KEY WORDS: Multiculturality, school textbooks, sex education,
sexually transmitted infection.
Christine Greenhow
Teacher Knowledge about Technology Integration: An Examination
of Inservice and Preservice Teachers Instructional Decision-making
ABSTRACT This study compared the abilities of inservice and
preservice teachers to demonstrate an understanding of
technology integration and to apply such knowledge to
instructional decision-making. Using a set of online content-specific
multimedia scenarios to resolve complex problems of teaching
with technology in a simulated school environment, inservice
teachers outperformed preservice teachers on criteria measuring
practical and pedagogical content knowledge about technology
integration; however, preservice and inservice teachers scored
similarly in their ability to make an instructional decision
about technology. In addition, both preservice and inservice
teachers demonstrated a lack of weighing competing options in
the case and a lack of orientation toward reflective and
adjustable practices. Overall, inservice teachers demonstrated
consideration of a broader range of classroom- and school-level
factors in making a technology integration decision.
Understanding, capturing, and measuring these differences is
essential to advance theory on the dimensions of technological
pedagogical content knowledge, and how it develops in different
teacher sub-groups to advance the work of teacher educators
concerned with designing courses about technology integration
appropriate to learners needs.
KEYWORDS: Teacher education, teacher knowledge, technology,
KALLIOPI THEODORAKI, SPIRIDON KAMPIOTIS
The Development of Movement Synthesis Ability Through the
Teaching of Creative Movement and Improvisation
ABSTRACT The purpose of the present study was to examine whether
the teaching of creative movement and improvisation can
influence the development of movement synthesis ability.
Movement synthesis ability refers to the production of a
movement composition. Twenty-five female freshmen, physical
education students, participated in the study. They created
their own series of movements improvising within a frame of
fundamental movements. Their movement synthesis ability was
measured on two occasions, before and after the experimental
treatment. The experimental group received 10 lessons of
creative movement and improvisation, while the control group did
not receive any lessons of this kind. The movement syntheses of
the subjects were evaluated by a 10-items scale. The statistical
analysis of the data showed that three variables of synthesis
ability were improved, namely, turns, changes of levels, and
changes in speed and intensity, indicating that the teaching of
creative movement and improvisation in the present study had a
positive impact on the development of these variables.
KEY WORDS: Creative movement, improvisation, movement
composition, synthesis ability, teaching methods.
WOLFGANG GRAEBER, MARTIN LINDNER, IPN Kiel
The Impact of the PARSEL Way to Teach Science in Germanyon
Interest, Scientific Literacy,and German National Standards
ABSTRACT: This paper shows how PARSEL modules help to realize
the German standards in practice. After analyzing the
disappointing results of the TIMSS- and PISA-studies, which
caused a kind of PISA-shock in Germany, and looking at school
systems of winning nations, several changes have been initiated
in the German educational system. The most radical change to the
German school system may be the introduction of national
education standards in 2004. These standards do not only focus
on the content as did the former curricula, but also stress the
development of competences, which should be attained by the
ninthand tenth-grade students who reach the middle level (Secondary
I) examination. Pre-tests (questionnaire and group interviews)
indicated that the students like to do experiments, like to work
on topics from their everyday life, and they consider science (chemistry)
to be an important school subject. Furthermore, the pre-tests
showed that students like to self-regulate their work, to choose
their own content and goals, and to invent their own ways to
solve problems. But, this was only partly true; deeper
interviews revealed that at least low-achieving students aim to
be prepared for the next test, and they prefer well-structured
lessons,
which are usually dominated by a well explaining teacher. More
surprisingly, we identified that student opinions changed after
studying PARSEL modules. For example, after completing the
module Which soap is best? students reported that they really
enjoyed the feeling of autonomy and the inclusion of everyday
life topics during their self-regulated learning process.
KEYWORDS: Interest, intrinsic motivation, self-regulated
learning, socio-scientific decision making.
Pangratios Papacosta
The Mystery in Science: A Neglected Tool for Science Education
Of the many valuable tools available to science education, the
mystery in science is the one that is the most ignored,
underused, or misunderstood. Whenever it is used, it is only as
mere entertainment or as an attention grabber. In a recent essay
titled Impedance Matching1 Robert P. Crease praises the efforts
of his colleague Clifford Swartz, a physicist at Stony Brook,
for his ability to use wonder and mystery in keeping students
interest in physics alive. But the mystery quality in science
should do much more than that. Appropriately integrated in
teaching, the mystery in science can improve student attitudes
and generate a life-long interest in science. It may even prompt
students to take a closer look at science as a possible career.
JOSÉ ANTONIO TORRES GONZÁLEZ
The Union of the Cultures in the School: Education and Audio-visual
Communication
ABSTRACT: The item in the environment which is going to turn
this work is multiculturalism, namely, the existence of several
different cultures in one nation or in the same geographical
reality, which accepts diversity and tolerates the maintenance
of the cultural identity of all and each of minority groups (Advanced
Teaching English Dictionary, 1998 edition, Ed. SM page. 841).This
happens in the school due to the current immigration movement.
Therefore, after establishing the legal and theoretical base of
our work, we will record the importance that schools have
remedial education, thus justifying the need to implement our
project. This first part will be more theoretical, and, with it,
we will give rise to a second practice that is to be proposed in
a draft standard for those centers that are displayed in various
cultures. Our intention is that through it, our students (whether
immigrants or not) be prepared to function in different social
networks in which, within a dynamic of dialogue, contact with
other schools exposures and via videoconference, so our students
will have theopportunity to learn more about other cultures.
KEY WORDS: Education, cultures, inmigratory, multiculturality,
videoconference.
GEORGIOS TSAPARLIS
Using PARSEL Modules to Contextualizing the States-Of-Matter
Approach (SOMA) to Introductory Chemistry
ABSTRACT: SOMA (States-Of-Matter Approach) is an introductory
chemistry program for all students in the tenth or eleventh
grade (age 16-17), which introduces chemistry through the
separate study of the three states of matter. SOMA is basically
a formalistic approach. In this paper, we discuss the use of
PARSEL modules in providing a teaching approach to SOMA. This
has been realized using two PARSEL modules. One module (which
can be covered within the SOMA major unit on Gases) is about
carbon dioxide in carbonated beverages and relates to gas
solubility in liquids, gas pressure, gas laws, physical and
chemical equilibrium, and acidbase chemistry. The second module
(which can be covered within the SOMA major unit on Solids)
includes salt, salts, crystals and crystal structure, ionic
bonding, uses of salt, and its role in human health. It is
proposed that a large number of other PARSEL modules can also be
coupled with and used in SOMA.
KEYWORDS: PARSEL approach, scientific literacy, States-Of-Matter
Approach (SOMA).